Insurance Protection You Can Trust

Peace of mind and customizable insurance coverage all in one place.

Peace of Mind

McIvor Insurance Agency is your trusted insurance agent located in Chagrin Falls, Ohio. We are dedicated to protecting the things in life that are most important to you. We strive to provide customer service that’s GUARANTEED to give you peace of mind!

More than just a number!

As an independent agency located in Chagrin Falls, Ohio, we have access to the leading insurance companies, allowing us to constantly monitor the insurance marketplace to offer you an affordable protection program that is customized to fit your individual or business needs.

We are currently licensed in Ohio, Florida, Texas, Rhode Island, California, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Washington, and Illinois.

Please call us today at (440) 708-3488.

Insurance Categories We Specialize In

Commercial Insurance

Life Insurance

Personal Umbrella

Renter’s Insurance

Home Insurance

Auto Insurance

Courtney McIvor of McIvor Insurance Agency has provided our company with excellent professional service. We are headquartered in Ohio and have satellite locations in multiple states. She has been able to fluidly move through the obstacles and nuances of each state with ease. Courtney maintains open lines of communication so we never have to worry where we are in the process. She is ahead of the game and initiates status updates. What sets the McIvor Insurance Agency apart is the personal service. When working with Courtney, we feel as if we are her only client. Her personal touch includes handling of our account during evening hours and on the weekends. The phrase “Whatever it takes” epitomizes the relationship between our company and the McIvor Insurance Agency.

Marc T.

I asked Courtney to give me some life insurance options. She got right on it. We met, and she explained all of my options as well as the positive and negatives to the different plans. She is very knowledgeable and highly recommend her.

Dennis B.

Courtney was very helpful and knowledgeable. She helped me find a home/auto policy that provided greater coverage than my current policy and reduced my premium. I would definitely recommend her!

Tiffany M.

We are so glad we went with McIvor Insurance Agency. We saved so much without sacrificing coverage, but most of all it’s the PERSONAL attention we received from Courtney McIvor. Any questions we had she always got back to us right away and made us feel like a VIP. We would strongly encourage everyone to call Courtney McIvor for your home and auto needs.

Stephen B

My husband & I asked Courtney to review the home & auto policies we had with another provider. After the review, she recommended coverage that we were not offered with our previous insurance company. This additional coverage gave us a better piece of mind knowing that we were fully covered if something were to happen. We have been very pleased by her service, follow up, and suggestions. We highly recommend Courtney & McIvor Insurance Company for all of your insurance needs.

Michelle & Jeff B.

When the unexpected happens, let us cover it.

What is an umbrella insurance policy?

An umbrella insurance policy is a type of personal liability coverage that goes above and beyond the amount that regular home or vehicle insurance offers. To have umbrella insurance, you must own standard condo or homeowners, auto, or watercraft policy first. The umbrella policy then begins covering after the regular coverage has been exhausted.